I am discovering it arduous to DM for an Oath of the Ancients Paladin PC in my group.
My concern is he is not following his tenets in addition to he might be, however I am extra inquisitive about what requirements I must be holding his role-playing at moderately than punish/take care of him.
Kindle the Mild-
By way of your acts of mercy, kindness, and forgiveness, kindle the sunshine of hope on the earth, beating again despair.
Shelter the Mild-
The place there may be good, magnificence, love, and laughter on the earth, stand towards the wickedness that might swallow it.
The place life prospers, stand towards the forces that might render it barren.
Protect Your Personal Mild-
Enjoyment of track and laughter, in magnificence and artwork.
For those who enable the sunshine to die in your individual coronary heart, you may’t protect it on the earth.
Be the Mild-
Be a wonderful beacon for all who dwell in despair.
Let the sunshine of your pleasure and braveness shine forth in all of your deeds.
The primary level that we disagree on is that his oath is all about nature and is not involved with issues that do not straight have an effect on it.
Instance: He is okay with overlooking corruption in a authorities that might consequence within the dying of innocents, as long as a forest would not get burned down within the course of and no animals are harmed.
The Oath of the Ancients is as previous because the race of elves and the rituals of the druids.
Typically known as fey knights, inexperienced knights, or horned knights, paladins who swear this oath forged their lot with the facet of the sunshine within the cosmic wrestle towards darkness as a result of they love the attractive and life-giving issues of the world, not essentially as a result of they consider in ideas of honor, braveness, and justice.
They adorn their armor and clothes with photos of rising issues—leaves, antlers, or flowers—to replicate their dedication to preserving life and light-weight on the earth.
Whereas the outline of the oath in addition to a few of their spells definitely suggest a deep connection to nature, I really feel as if the tenets are written to embody extra than simply issues in regards to the security and preservation of nature.
I really feel as if there’s a sure stage of contradiction between the tenets and the above textual content in daring, particularly their perception in honor, braveness, and justice.
As long as it would not have an effect on nature, might this oath enable a paladin to:
- Journey with evil aligned characters with none try at reforming them?
- Forego forgiveness in favor of killing somebody who betrayed him?
- Overlook the evil and wrongdoings of man? (or any sentient race)
- Inflict harm on somebody for mendacity to him?
The query to be answered:
Leaving character alignment out of the equation, how a lot separation must be allowed for this oath relating to the legal guidelines of nature vs the legal guidelines of man?